It's a sad day when you find yourself agreeing with something that Hone Harawira said about the ACT Party. But today is that day:
"Your attempts to boost Act in the polls by riding on the xenophobic fears of Joe Bloggs in the street will not work this time round."
And he is dead right. It's a dumb strategy and it won't work. There is no way to describe ACT's latest newspaper ad other than
INSANELY FUCKING STUPID. I haven't even read it. I don't care to. I don't even care if I agree with what it says or not. It's still an INSANELY FUCKING STUPID ad. The economy is in the toilet, and ACT are running ads race-baiting? Why?!
Here's what I think happened. I think this is John Ansell's baby - he thought it up and wanted to do it, and he convinced the powers that be that it was a good idea, because John did the 2005 National Party billboards and everyone thinks he is some sort of God among men because of it. But one good campaign does not make you a genius with every brain fart you have. Even the best campaigners have bad days and bad ideas, which is why you always have the politician whose arse is on the line make the calls and commission the ideas. You don't let your staff decide what your campaign is going to be. Especially not John Ansell, who is a part of the excreable Coastal Coalition and wants to push that whole race-baiting paranoid son-of-John-Birch agenda where property rights are okay for white people, but not for brown ones. Unfortunately, they now seem to have a toehold in ACT and this is what they want to push, rather than the sound economic policy and liberality of ACT's founding.
If ACT's brand was in the gutter before, it is digging half way to Spain now. I wouldn't even put money on Banks winning Epsom - if National select Aaron Bhatnagar, he will romp in and ACT will be dead. And on current form, it will be a good thing too.
The effect of ACT, and MMP on New Zealand political discourse has been devastating. It is no coincidence that 1994, the year of ACT's foundation, was the last time we had a decent right wing government in New Zealand that truly progressed freedom. ACT took good political ideas from both Labour and National, stuck them in a ghetto with 5% of the vote, and that is where those ideas have stayed ever since. There's been a few good things that wouldn't have happened without ACT - time-limited Treaty claims, ACC competition, three strikes, and (hopefully soon) voluntary student unions, but the big stuff - the idea that government should be small, the idea that people should be trusted as adults to do as they please if they are not harming others, the idea that taxes should be flat and low, the idea that welfare should get people off their arse and into work... all have stayed in an intellectual ghetto of ACT's own making.
More tragic than this is the people who have stuck with ACT and will go down with it. Talented folk like David Seymour and Cathy Odgers will presumably stand for ACT as candidates this year, when they really should be in one of the major parties where the real decisions are made. Instead they will stand in this election - the party will disintegrate, and they will spend another ten years fluffing around trying to get somewhere in National, which they will inevitably join because if they want to do anything in politics they will have no other choice. And nobody in National will respect them for it.
None of this gives me any pleasure. And there are bloggers out there who whinge about me being a toy-chucker and a party-hopper, but I've been consistent in what I believe and consistently the canary in this mine, and none of my critics have anything to show for their lame-arsed silence themselves, with the possible exception of Bhatnagar if he wins the Epsom nomination. The truth is that we on the Right have blown it, and blown it big time. It will take another generation for us to get back on our feet in New Zealand, and even then only if we learn from our mistakes over the last 17 years.
Let's stop flogging the dead horse of ACT, stop digging up the political cemetery for candidates, start up some think-tanks, get a Tea Party movement together, join National, and get some decent candidates nominated for seats. That's how we win. It'll take us twenty years, but for God's sake, lets stop fucking around with this third party MMP crap and start now!
Labels: Blair Mulholland